I didn't mind the Dumbledore. He wasn't the same, but he wasn't agressively not-Dumbledore either.

Peter shouldnt have been fat, I agree. But Timothy Spall was still good.

I loved the Whomping Willow too.

Also. I can't help wondering why the tattoos etc? Did I forget them or are they not in the book? Because he can't have got them done while in Azkaban and yet getting lots of tattoos doesnt really fit with my image of pre-Azkaban Sirius. Okay, one or two maybe. But looking like that?